HotnHit Newsfeatures



Home I Editorial I Views I Issues I Politics I Economy I Agriculture I Society I Culture I History I Development I Entertainment I Environment I Science I Sports I Wildlife


India: Role of MHA and Media Reporting questioned in Fasih Mehmood deportation case


Monday June 09, 2014


"A recent press release issued by Jamia Teachers’ Solidarity Association (JTSA), New Delhi, alleges that media reporting looks irresponsible, at times, while bringing to fore the case of arrest of Fasih Mahmood while role of Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA), India, remained dubious.


HNF Correspondent


JSTA, in September, brought out a report, Framed, Damned, Acquitted documenting 16 cases where trials of terror accused had resulted in acquittals for not only lack of evidence but obviously concocted evidence. Each of these cases was accompanied by a section on how media had publicly tried and ‘executed’ these unfortunate men when they were first arrested—to abandon them or bury their stories in the inside pages when they were later acquitted. The release of the report had generated a genuine interest in the media – and one may dare saying, an introspection of the media’s own role as the handmaiden of the investigative agencies.

The recent release from JTSA said, while questioning media role again in another case, ‘the reportage surrounding the deportation of Fasih Mehmood has belied the expectations of all those who were hoping for a more balanced reporting in arrests of those alleged to be terrorists by agencies.


While television channels led in competitive shrillness, the newspapers were not far behind. Most mainstream papers published the statements of those accused and charge-sheeted in the Chinnaswami blasts or the Jama Masjid shootout to pin the culpability of Fasih Mehmood in terrorist activities.  These statements, the newspapers can hardly be unaware, have no value as evidence in the courts, and yet they are used routinely to build a story of guilt.  One newspaper has even gone ahead and published Fasih’s Interrogation report (“5 IM members still holed up in Saudi, says Fasih”, TNN, 23 October). Unnamed police sources have been rampantly quoted.  On the whole, the media has chosen not to question the version of the investigative agencies, which is getting more colourful and convoluted with every passing day.’

However, ‘The agencies till date have been unable to put together a credible sequence of events regarding Fasih’s arrest’, said the release adding that “Hard pressed to explain how Fasih found himself in Saudi custody in the first place, a story is being suddenly pushed now that Fasih was arrested and serving time in Saudi for a ‘minor visa related crime’. This is a new revelation and was never ever placed before the SC which had directed the MHA and various agencies to locate Fasih Mehmood.”

The release pointed at some media reports about a red corner notice that was issued in May 2012 and said, they (the reports) conveniently forgot to add that it was issued only ‘after’ Fasih’s wife Nikhat moved a habeas corpus petition in the Supreme Court.

While mentioning that the Ministry of Home Affairs’ (MHA) affidavit filed before the apex court stated that a trial court in Delhi had issued an arrest warrant against Fasih, on 26 December 2011, for his alleged involvement in the Jama Masjid bomb blast case (2010), JTSA release questioned, ‘If indeed this was the case, what took the agencies more than five months to issue a red corner notice? Were they working the back channels with the Saudi government as hinted by some newspapers reports? In which case and how did the MHA state under oath to the Supreme Court that Indian agencies had no role in his arrest in Saudi?’

Hinting upon gloating by the Secretary, MHA, over his ‘prize catch’, the release mentions that ‘in days after Fasih’s detention in Saudi, when Fasih’s family members had approached him, he had feigned total ignorance about his whereabouts. When precisely did he learn that this 'much-wanted man' had been detained in Saudi Arabia?’

These questions need to be asked to the MHA and the assorted agencies tripping over each other to claim credit for Fasih’s arrest, said the release.


If you look at issues from the

perspective of common man


want to share your ideas with our readers across the globe

submit your article

(at least 800 words)


blog comments powered by Disqus
About Us I Contact Us I Get Our Guideline
Copy Right 2004 @ HOTnHIT Newsfeatures, Bhubaneswar, INDIA